Head to head · SEC data as of September 11, 2026
Progressive
82
Quality score · out of 100
Allstate
88
Quality score · out of 100
Allstate comes in ahead: a quality score of 88 versus 82 for Progressive. Allstate wins on net margin (19% vs 12.8%), ROE (39.5% vs 34.1%) and earnings growth (21.3% vs 14.1%). Progressive answers with revenue growth (14.8% vs 9.8%).
| Metric | Progressive | Allstate |
|---|---|---|
| Quality score (0-100) | 82 | 88 |
| Net margin | 12.8% | 19% |
| Gross margin | — | — |
| ROE | 34.1% | 39.5% |
| Net debt/EBITDA | — | — |
| FCF margin | 17.5% | 17.5% |
| Revenue growth (annualized) | 14.8% | 9.8% |
| Earnings growth (annualized) | 14.1% | 21.3% |
TTM metrics with official SEC data, refreshed daily. Bold green marks the winner of each metric. A dash means the metric doesn't apply or isn't reliable.
Progressive. Progressive is the most profitable U.S. auto insurer and the fastest share gainer. Its historic edge: pricing risk better than anyone with data (it pioneered telematics — measuring how you actually drive).
Allstate. Allstate is one of America's largest auto and home insurers — the 'good hands' of its slogan. A massive personal-lines business where the battle is fought on price, claims costs and national-scale advertising.
Open your account in minutes with regulated brokers and buy U.S. and European stocks from small amounts. No paperwork.
The serious investor's standard
Open free account →Anyone who wants low commissions and access to almost any market in the world.
Popular in the U.S.
Open free account →Anyone investing in the U.S. who wants a powerful, commission-free stock app.
Investing carries risk of loss.
What this comparison doesn't tell you
The score measures business quality, not whether the stock is cheap or expensive: the better company can be the worse investment if you overpay. For the valuation verdict, enter each one's current price in the analyzer:
Who has the stronger fundamentals today, Progressive or Allstate?
By the StockSemáforo model (profitability, growth and financial strength, built on official SEC data), Allstate scores higher: 88 versus 82 out of 100. The score is recomputed nightly with the latest filings.
Does that make Allstate the better investment?
No. The score measures business quality, not valuation: an excellent company can trade at an excessive price and be a poor investment at that price. To find out whether it's cheap or expensive, enter its current quote in the StockSemáforo analyzer.
Other comparisons
Visa vs Mastercard · Visa vs American Express · PayPal vs Block · JPMorgan vs Bank of America · Goldman Sachs vs Morgan Stanley · See all comparisons →
Who's behind the methodology and model · how the score is computed
Data: official SEC filings (EDGAR) · Recomputed on September 11, 2026
Spotted a figure that looks wrong? Report it and we'll review it.